Monday, January 04, 2010

Two Community Leaders Get A Grade Of "F" For Buying The DOE Propaganda That Jamaica High School Should Be Closed.

I read with a mixture of amusement and anger as two clueless community leaders thought it was a great idea that Jamaica High School will be closed and be replaced with three smaller schools. The New York Daily News allowed these two apologists for Joel Klein's destructive policy in closing large, traditional high schools to express their ignorance of the DOE's policy to destroy these neighborhood schools and put in small or charter schools that will try to exclude the neediest of the children in their community from these very schools.

To prove why Jamaica High School should be closed down they brought up the poor graduation rate of under 50% and the lack of students who want to go to the school (88). They also claimed that Jamaica High School fared poorly when compared to similar schools. What they fail to understand, or don't want to understand, the reasons behind the poor graduation rate, the lack of student selections, and the alleged comparison with similar schools. It is because of the destructive policy by the DOE that put Jamaica High School in danger of closing in the first place.

First, the poor graduation rate can be attributed to the failed policy of Chancellor Joel Klein who started an irreversible plague by closing down the high schools south of Jamaica High School (August Martin, Springfield Gardens, and Far Rockaway) and dumping many of the "at risk" students that the smaller schools refused to select into the school. It is common knowledge that many of the small schools claim that they do not have the services or resources to educate the ELL and Special Education students and push them to the large traditional schools like Jamaica High School. Furthermore, until recently the DOE allowed these small schools to "cherry pick" their students not only excluding the above mention groups but children that were level 1 with behavioural or attendance issues. It is little wonder that these schools showed an initial jump in the graduation rate. Presently, these schools are still trying their best to encourage level 3 & 4 students with good attendance and little discipline issues to go to their school while discouraging the "at risk" students to select the school due to lack of services for them. In today's edition, the New York Daily News article wrote that the UFT claimed how unfair this is with regard to charter schools. However, let's see what these graduation rates are a decade from now? I suspect they will be no better and maybe worse than the large traditional high schools they replaced since these small schools will be competing with other small schools and charter schools for students and must fill their schools with "warm bodies" or risk being closed down themselves.

Second, the poor leadership of a previous Principal and incompetence of some of his administrators that are no longer at the school resulted in the State wrongly putting the school on their "most dangerous list of schools" . Once placed on this list the school not only lost existing students but labeled it to parents as too dangerous for their children who were considering going there. It did not matter that the school was safe and had quiet hallways and a great learning environment and was taken off the State list a year later. The damage was done and to the outsider Jamaica had a scarlet letter on it. The DOE, rather than correcting a wrong, cut resources, and space at the school and hastened the school's spiral downward.

Finally, these two clueless community leaders said that Jamaica High School, when compared to similar schools, did poorly. Really? Where are these similar schools? Do they have the same population and income distribution as Jamaica High School? Did these schools suffer from a similar brain drain as smaller and charter schools in the area siphoned off these high achieving students. Moreover, and more importantly, were these so called similar schools get their fair share of "at risk" students as nearby large high schools were shut down? I would venture a guess that they do not have the answers to my questions.

It is unfortunate that people who are supposed to be intelligent believe the DOE's fuzzy math, phony report card grades, and a lack of real accountability as the basis of their faulty conclusion that a potentially great school like Jamaica High School should be closed. Had they dug deeper into the numbers I would bet that they would be singing a different tune. However, their failure to explore the closing of Jamaica High School more closely allows the DOE propaganda spin machine to continue and allow a once great school like Jamaica High School to close.


Anonymous said...


What is happening is that we are witnessing a real estate grab by the DoE for the benefit of Hedge Fund Managers and Billionaires, pet projects.

This is called privatization of public education.

No doubt the new boutique schools in that same building will have all the modern conveniencies.

The building will be repared and made ready for a far different class of student.

They will not be of the same ethnicity as in the neighborhood.

They will be bused in and wear expensive uniforms.

They will have new labs and computer labs.

The building will be occupied by newby teachers who cannot teach a fraction as well as the current staff of seasoned pro's now working in that grand old building.

The impact of this decision by the Fascist GruppenFuehrers will be felt in multiple ways.

Students will have to travel for hours out of the neighborhood to go to school.

Jamaica High School Teachers will be consigned to the ATR pool to await further debasement.

The proud and noble institutional memory of what a school really is, will be erased.

So much of institutional memory has been erased through ageism and the Latex Latrines, this is yet, another final nail in the coffin.

Funny thing is, it only happens in Latino and African American communities.

Race and economic class play a major role in the draconian edicts being handed on down from the Reich Chancelery.

We are getting a first hand lesson in fascim.

What ever became of the democratic process and standard human and constitutional rights?

This is just the start of corporatization of the state education system.

Maybe they will outsource teachers so as to cut costs.

There has to be some type of injunction put on this process, for it's inherently unamerican and anti-constitutional ramifications and effects.

If there ever was such a thing as a "community leader", the person calling themselves by that label should organize legal action to put a stop to these despotic and racist edicts being handed down by the Plutocratic-Oligarchy of Rich Fascists and Robber Barons.

What is needed is a general strike by all unions that have anything to do with NYC public schools.

It's time to stop all that drivel about Vichy collaboration and finally take a stand.

Organized labor by it's very nature, is always in a position opposed to management. What the hell happened to the entire point of having a union?

We need action not a bloated sellout patronage mill.

To all the sheep out there, who nervously bleat about the Taylor Laws, and two for one. Grow a bloody pair of bollocks and stand up for what's right.

If you settle for nothing now. You will settle for nothing later.

Angry Nog

Anonymous said...

actually, in the op-ed, they said the reasons DIDN'T MATTER. that's possibly even more agregious than not recognizing or understanding the reasons, because it permits it to happen over and over again...just as we've seen.

Anonymous said...

make that egregious. sorry, typo...

NY_I said...

The attack against Jamaica HS and company are based on mere lies. I put up a post debunking the lies, Haimson et al's "NYC Schools Under Bloomberg /Klein has the analysis; I joined this with more data, from the NYSED itself:
In short, the small schools that the DOE is biased for, do no better than the established large comprehensive schools. See my latest post, citing numerous small and large schools at

Anonymous said...

Hello to all...

I look forward to meeting you all.

Thank you,


[url=]Search Engine Optimization[/url]

NY_I said...

Yep, the city gives the short end of the resources stick to Latino and African-Ameridan students.

Along these lines, the Post reports that the city's DOE is denying English Language Learner services. There's been no decline of immigrant students. Yet, why the erosion of services?

nisha said...

Thanks for sharing this powerful information.That's very helpful and